Oxford College is organized into four academic Divisions: History and Social Sciences, Humanities, Mathematics and Science, and Physical Education and Dance. Each academic division is represented by a chairperson who is appointed by the Dean of Academic Affairs after consultation with all tenure-track members of the division. Chairs are appointed for three years and may be reappointed.
| History and Social Sciences | Humanities | Natural Sciences and Mathematics | Physical Education and Dance |
| Anthropology | Art | Biology | Aquatics |
| Economics | English | Chemistry | Lifetime Activities |
| History | Languages | Geology | Health and Fitness |
| Music | Mathematics and Computer Science | ||
| Psychology | Philosophy |
Physics and Astronomy | |
| Sociology | Religion | ||
| Theater |